EUVIMEDOpdag EUVIMED
CrossrefInfokort

Classroom Integration of AI-Simulated Patients and Automated Feedback in Doctoral Psychotherapy Training: Longitudinal Mixed Methods Study

Ellen Converse, Ryan Louie, Debra Safer, Juan Pablo Pacheco, William Fang, Jamie Kent, Bruce Arnow, Diyi Yang

Interactive Journal of Medical Research · 2026-11-11 · 15 · e93199-e93199

DOI: 10.2196/93199 ↗
AbstractBibliografiske oplysninger

Abstract

Abstract Background Psychotherapy education increasingly emphasizes technology-assisted methods that extend deliberate practice beyond human supervision. AI has enabled automated skill assessment and patient simulations, yet few studies have examined how students experience such tools in real-world settings alongside established practice modalities. Objective We aimed to evaluate students’ experiences with AI-augmented deliberate practice embedded in an existing psychotherapy course sequence. Secondary aims included identifying implementation barriers, ethical and pedagogical considerations, and factors influencing students’ acceptance of AI-assisted learning. Methods Participants were 29 first-year clinical psychology doctoral students in a 2-quarter psychotherapy sequence at an American Psychological Association–accredited program. In the fall course, students completed weekly peer role-plays and could optionally submit transcripts to CARE for AI feedback to supplement peer feedback. In the winter course, students completed required weekly deliberate practice through Skillsetter video vignettes and could optionally practice with CARE’s voice-based AI-simulated patients, receiving AI and instructor feedback afterward. Surveys with Likert-type and free-response items were voluntary in the fall and required in the winter; 9 and 25 students completed them, respectively. Analyses included descriptive statistics, matched-pairs testing, and thematic analysis. Results In the fall course (n=9), where privacy concerns and survey nonresponse limited data on AI feedback, students rated peer feedback higher than AI feedback on being constructive and helpful (median 3, IQR 3-3 vs median 2, IQR 2-2; P =.02) and recognizing areas to improve (mean 5.22, SD 0.83 vs mean 4.33, SD 0.87; P =.046), citing transcription errors and a narrow focus on empathy while valuing AI’s alternative phrasing. In the winter course (n=25), Skillsetter was rated higher than CARE only for learning from mistakes (mean 4.52, SD 2.00 vs mean 3.20, SD 2.04; P =.03); immersion, spontaneous responding, communication beyond words, and alliance building did not differ significantly. Students valued CARE for interactive practice not possible with vignettes but reported undetected vocal pauses (20/25, 80%), insufficient realism (14/25, 56%), and limited emotional expression (13/25, 52%), and raised concerns about AI replacing peer support (22/25, 88%) and peer interaction (20/25, 80%). Asked about AI broadly, students expressed mixed views, citing concerns about supplanted relational dynamics, nonconsensual data use, and generative AI’s environmental impacts. Conclusions Embedding AI-augmented deliberate practice into an existing course sequence was feasible, but students’ experiences favored established methods: they preferred human over AI feedback and described video vignettes as more realistic than voice-based AI interactions, while valuing AI-simulated patients for interactive practice other modalities could not provide. Implementation barriers included feedback quality, transcription accuracy, and instructor time required to supplement AI feedback. Perceptions of AI’s instructional utility appeared contingent on students’ trust in the technology, suggesting future deployments should weigh a sample’s attitudes toward AI and its value relative to existing training resources.

Viden, der passer til dit arbejde.

Fra en gratis start over personlig litteratursøgning til den komplette Research Suite.

Se priser →

Er alle forlagsfuldtekster inkluderet?

Nej. Bibliografiske referencer, abstracts og fuldtekster er forskellige typer indhold. Om en fuldtekst er tilgængelig, afhænger af kilden, Open Access og dine eksisterende licenser. Et EUVIMED-abonnement erstatter ikke yderligere forlagsrettigheder.

Se priser →