Comparison of efficacy and safety of different treatment modalities for hemorrhoids: A network meta-analysis
World Journal of Gastroenterology · 2027-01-14 · 33 (2)
DOI: 10.3748/wjg.125931 ↗Abstract
BACKGROUND Hemorrhoidal disease is a prevalent anorectal condition for which a variety of interventional treatments are available; however, their comparative efficacy and complication profiles remain incompletely defined. AIM To compare the clinical effectiveness and safety of hemorrhoidal treatments via a network meta-analysis. METHODS We systematically searched major electronic databases for randomized controlled trials published up to June 2026. A Bayesian network meta-analysis was performed to compare the 20 interventions in terms of recurrence, efficacy, patient satisfaction, subsequent treatment rate, and adverse events, with subgroup analyses stratified by Goligher grade. RESULTS Sixty-six studies encompassing 8549 patients and 20 therapeutic modalities were included. LigaSure™ hemorrhoidectomy demonstrated a significantly lower recurrence risk than Milligan–Morgan hemorrhoidectomy [odds ratio (OR) = 0.18, 95% credible interval (95%CI): 0.03–0.94] and ranked first in effectiveness [surface under the cumulative ranking curve (SUCRA) = 98.2%], with the lowest further treatment rate (SUCRA = 4.3%), although it ranked higher for pain (82.5%) and urinary retention (75.4%). The tissue-selecting technique showed a nearly significant reduction in recurrence (OR = 0.210, 95%CI: 0.037–1.000) and improvements in safety outcomes, particularly anorectal stenosis (SUCRA = 20.0%) and constipation (11.7%). Direct current electrotherapy also showed a favorable SUCRA ranking for recurrence, but this result was derived from a very limited number of studies with small sample sizes. Rubber band ligation was associated with a markedly higher recurrence risk (OR = 6.7; SUCRA = 90.5%), as was injection sclerotherapy (SUCRA = 76.4%); both interventions had low effectiveness rankings. Subgroup analyses suggested that procedure performance might vary by Goligher grade, with LigaSure™ hemorrhoidectomy and the tissue-selecting technique showing potential advantages in severe (grade ≥ III) disease, although these findings should be interpreted with caution because of limited data. CONCLUSION LigaSure™ hemorrhoidectomy and the tissue-selecting technique are preferred for surgical candidates with severe disease; rubber band ligation and sclerotherapy are better suited for mild disease or for patients who are not surgical candidates. Treatment selection may be individualized according to disease severity, although the current evidence for grade-based recommendations remains exploratory.
EUVIMED