The Missense Mutant ClC-5 (E211A) Associated with Proton/Chloride Uncoupling Exacerbates Renal Pathology Compared with the ClC-5–Null Mutant
Kidney360 · 2026-10 · 7 (10) · 2219-2232
DOI: 10.34067/kid.0000001258 ↗Abstract
Key Points The ClC-5 E211A uncoupling mutation causes more severe and progressive kidney injury than loss of ClC-5. E211A-mutant mice develop age-dependent renal fibrosis, glomerular injury, and tubular degeneration that are absent in ClC-5 null mice. Uncoupling mutations cause pathogenic effects beyond loss of function, highlighting the need for mutation-specific therapies in Dent 1 disease. Background Dent disease type 1 is an X-linked proximal tubulopathy caused by mutations in CLCN5 , which encodes the chloride/proton exchanger ClC-5. Although loss-of-function mutations impair endocytosis and lead to progressive renal disease, the pathologic consequences of uncoupling mutations that selectively disrupt Cl − /H + exchange remain incompletely understood. Methods In this study, we examined the renal phenotype associated with the ClC-5 E211A uncoupling mutation, which abolishes proton transport while preserving chloride conductance, and compared it with that of ClC-5 null mice. Results Contrary to the expectation that partial transport activity would mitigate disease severity, E211A-mutant mice developed more severe and progressive kidney pathology than null mutants. Both models exhibited early low-molecular-weight proteinuria, including marked urinary excretion of β 2-microglobulin and vitamin D-binding protein. However, E211A mutants displayed progressive polyuria, reduced body weight, and pronounced interstitial fibrosis at 5 and 18 months of age, changes not observed in ClC-5 null mice. Renal injury in E211A mutants was characterized by glomerular abnormalities, including enlarged Bowman's spaces, cyst formation, reduced podocyte markers Wilms tumor protein and nephrin, and age-dependent tubular degeneration. ClC-5 E211A protein showed altered localization and reduced expression in vivo , suggesting disrupted trafficking or stability. Phenotypic severity was strongly influenced by genetic background, underscoring its modulatory role in disease expression. Conclusions Together, these findings demonstrate that the ClC-5 E211A uncoupling mutation induces additional adverse effects that exceed those caused by complete loss of ClC-5. Our results reveal that uncoupling mutations can drive progressive kidney damage through mechanisms distinct from gene knockout and highlight the need for mutation-specific therapeutic strategies for Dent disease type 1.
EUVIMED