Perspectives: On the Medicare crisis
Canadian Bulletin of Medical History · 1984
DOI: 10.3138/cbmh.1.1.115 ↗Abstract
There is said to be a crisis in medicare and that it is centred on the issue of direct charges in the form of extra billing, user fees and premiums. These charges contribute only a very small amount to the cost of health care services—extra billing accounts for only 2% of the total income of doctors—thus the furore may seem disproportionate. Obviously the issues go deeper. It is not just the fear, expressed by Emmett Hall and Monique Begin amongst others, that the present scale of direct charges represents the thin end of the wedge, threatening the fundamental principles of medicare and particularly equal access and portability between provinces. The medicare debate also forces us to think about priorities for resource allocation in the whole area of social policy and draws attention to the long term issues of the relationship between medical treatment and the health status of the population, and the proper balance between cure and care. The danger of using direct charges as a means of solving the perceived immediate cost-crunch is not only that the principles of medicare may be seriously eroded, but also that little will have been done to confront the more fundamental problems facing the system.
EUVIMED