The Impact of Unions on Job Satisfaction: A Review
International Journal of Health Management and Tourism · 2022
DOI: 10.31201/ijhmt.1057428 ↗Abstract
In the last 40 years, the effect of unions on job satisfaction has attracted the attention of those working in the fields of economics, industrial relations, and industrial psychology. It is known that in most of the studies in the literature, this effect results in negative and ‘out of the reasonable framework’. In studies published in recent years, it has been found that the direction of this effect has changed. This shows that the relationship between the union and job satisfaction is more complex than it seems. In this review, the studies in English that are evaluated by scanning the Web of Science® database are included in the SSCI, SCI-Expanded, ESCI, CPCI-SSH indexes. It is discussed in these research articles and academic papers, that according to which criteria the predictive variables used while investigating the effect in question were determined. As a result, in the literature, it is seen that membership status, unionization rate, the employee to be within the scope of the union, and the existence of the union in the workplace are determined as the union variables. While concurrency between union variables and job satisfaction is often not taken into account in the exit-voice hypotheses, it is seen that the instrumental variable and fixed-effect models have been developed to solve the endogeneity problem caused by concurrent causality in the ‘reverse causality’ hypotheses. Especially considering the problem of endogeneity highlighted in the ‘reverse causality’ hypotheses, in this study, a model in which the effect of the employees' perception of union effectiveness and job satisfaction on the dependent variable can be tested as the predictor variable for the labor relations systems where the benefits obtained from the union gains do not depend on the membership status and the employees do not have the opportunity of collective labor agreement through the unions.
EUVIMED