Optical Properties and Color Stability of Universal Single- and Group-Shade Resin Composites
Operative Dentistry · 2026-09 · 51 (5) · 479-493
DOI: 10.2341/26-034-l ↗Abstract
ABSTRACT Objectives: Simplified- or group-shade universal resin composites have recently been introduced to simplify shade selection for direct restorative procedures. However, the available evidence regarding their surface and optical properties remains limited. This study aimed to characterize the color properties and surface roughness of a single-shade and a group-shade resin composite before and after simulated aging. Methods and Materials: Sixty specimens (Ø 6 mm × 2 mm; n = 12) were fabricated: a multi-shade conventional nanofilled resin composite (Filtek Z350XT, 3M [now Solventum]), a single-shade nanofilled resin composite (Palfique Omnichroma, Tokuyama), and a group-shade nanofilled resin composite (Filtek Easy Match [FEM], Solventum, in the Natural, Bright, and Warm shades). Specimens were evaluated by reflectance spectrophotometry for CIE L*a*b*, translucency (TP ab and TP 00 ), whiteness index (W ID ), color stability (ΔE ab and ΔE 00 ), and fluorescence (F Z and F C ). Surface roughness (Ra) and topography were assessed using scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Analyses were performed after 24 hours and after 10,000 thermocycling cycles (5°C – 55°C). Data were analyzed using generalized linear models and the Kruskal-Wallis, Dunn, and paired Wilcoxon tests (α = 0.05). Results: After thermocycling, all materials showed increased L* and a* values and decreased b*, TP ab , and TP 00 values ( p < 0.0001). Fluorescence decreased in all materials ( p < 0.0001), except for Omnichroma, which exhibited the highest values at both time points. W ID values differed among the single- and group-shade materials (FEM Warm ≤ FEM Natural < FEM Bright ≤ Omnichroma). FEM showed lower ΔE ab and ΔE 00 values than Z350XT and Omnichroma ( p < 0.0001). Only Omnichroma exhibited increased surface roughness after thermocycling ( p = 0.017). SEM analysis revealed minimal topographical changes, dependent on material type and manufacturer. Conclusions: Thermocycling affected the optical properties of all materials. However, the extent of these changes depended on material composition and manufacturer. The group-shade resin composite demonstrated superior color and surface stability after thermocycling.
EUVIMED