Reducing Information Uncertainty in Hospital Wayfinding for People With Specific Needs: Findings From a Qualitative, Multimethod Study
JMIR Human Factors · 2026-11-09 · 13 · e106882
DOI: 10.2196/106882 ↗Abstract
Background Hospital wayfinding is a well-documented source of patient stress, yet people with sensory, cognitive, or mobility-related needs face additional information barriers that generic wayfinding research rarely resolves. Information uncertainty, rather than a simple lack of signage, has recently been proposed as a unifying construct for locating and diagnosing these barriers across the patient journey. Objective This study empirically applies a Stage-Touchpoint-Uncertainty coding framework across 2 structurally contrasting hospitals to identify the elements that constitute information uncertainty during hospital navigation, how patients with specific needs perceive and prioritize these elements, and how the resulting uncertainty peaks can inform the prioritization of wayfinding interventions. Methods We conducted a qualitative, multimethod study with 4 rounds of data collection between May 2024 and July 2025 at 2 university hospitals that differ in scale and spatial organization (hospital A: more than 1000 beds, decentralized multipavilion campus; hospital B: 890-bed comprehensive center with a historic core). Methods comprised expert accessibility walkthroughs, website accessibility and usability testing with users with severe visual impairment, user walkthroughs with mobile eye-tracking and think-aloud protocols, and focus groups homogeneous by impairment type (hearing, developmental/learning, physical/mobility, and older adults) to evaluate candidate signage designs. In total, 38 participants took part (36 research participants and 2 accessibility experts who conducted the heuristic walkthroughs). The mean age of user-walkthrough and focus-group participants was 38.0 (range 21-75) years; age was not recorded for experts or website-testing participants. Results Coding organized observations into a Stage-Touchpoint-Uncertainty matrix spanning 5 consolidated journey stages, from digital prearrival search through physical navigation to exit. Four recurring uncertainty mechanisms emerged: absence, where a needed cue is simply missing; equivocality, where cues are present but fail to converge on one meaning; perceptual degradation, where a cue is legible in principle but difficult to see or read; and cognitive-translation demand, where a legible cue still requires additional mental work to act on. Absence characterized the earliest stages, involving digital search and entry, whereas equivocality became dominant once participants were navigating the building physically and remained the most frequently coded pattern through exit. Priorities also diverged by impairment group and data source: participants with visual impairment prioritized the digital retrievability of information, whereas focus-group participants with developmental/learning impairments prioritized redundant multichannel coding, and those with physical/mobility impairments prioritized functional-eligibility information. Conclusions Information uncertainty in hospital wayfinding is best understood along 2 axes—the stage of the journey at which it occurs and the mechanism that produces it. Together, these axes support wayfinding interventions that target specific stages and are tailored to specific types of breakdown, with potential transferability to comparable hospital settings beyond the 2 studied here. Breakdowns corroborated across multiple sources and impairment groups should be prioritized first.
EUVIMED