How Does Contact With Social Workers Influence Outcomes for Users of Adult Social Care Services in the United Kingdom? A Realist Review
Health & Social Care in the Community · 2026-01 · 2026 (1)
DOI: 10.1155/hsc/8012571 ↗Abstract
Background Social care services are essential for supporting vulnerable individuals to achieve the best possible quality of life. Social workers are central to this process, facilitating service delivery to improve well‐being. This study reports a realist review examining how, why and under what circumstances interactions with social workers impact adult service users in the United Kingdom. Methods Comprehensive literature searches were conducted in key databases in April 2025 (updated May 2026) to identify studies exploring service users’ perspectives on social worker interactions. Literature was appraised for relevance, rigour and richness to refine an initial programme theory. Interpretive and retroductive analyses were used to develop context–mechanism–outcome configurations (CMOCs). These CMOCs informed a refined programme theory (RPT) explaining how and under what circumstances interactions between service users and social workers influence outcomes. Results A total of 14,830 papers were screened, and 308 full texts were assessed for eligibility, with 56 documents informing CMOC development. We found that interactions between social workers and service users were often limited in both duration and frequency, leading to negative experiences of social care and often producing unfavourable short‐term outcomes. Five inter‐related mechanisms were identified: relationship building and ongoing interaction, social workers’ approach to needs assessment and care arrangements, clear and transparent communication, resource mobilisation and matching to needs and cross‐system collaborative working processes and coordination. The CMOCs suggest that contextual factors, including resource availability, care processes, continuity of interactions and changes in service users’ needs over time, can activate or constrain the mechanisms through which outcomes are produced. There was little evidence that short‐term changes in service users’ lives resulting from these interactions translated into longer‐term improvements in quality of life or sustained well‐being. Conclusion This review informs our understanding of how social worker interactions with adult service users are shaped and the short‐term outcomes they produce. However, it remains unclear whether changes resulting from contact with social workers lead to sustained improvements in service users’ quality of life and well‐being, highlighting the need to test the RPT in real‐world social care settings.
EUVIMED