Acid alone does not digest: a lesson from nineteenth-century stomach physiology
Advances in Physiology Education · 2026-12-01 · 50 (4) · 1289-1293
DOI: 10.1152/advan.90024.2026 ↗Abstract
“Gastric acid” and “gastric juice” are commonly used as interchangeable terms, thus obscuring a distinction that took physiologists generations to establish. Hydrochloric acid denatures dietary protein, activates pepsinogen, and maintains the pH at which pepsin is active, but it does not itself hydrolyze peptide bonds (i.e., digest). Disentangling the interplay between acid and pepsin required independent, near-simultaneous work in Germany and the United States in the early 1830s, followed by Theodor Schwann’s isolation, in 1836, of a separate heat-sensitive agent he named pepsin. The elimination logic Schwann used to reach that conclusion, testing and ruling out each plausible alternative in turn, offers a reasoning model still worth teaching today.
EUVIMED