Temporal Stability of Vagally‐Mediated Heart Rate Variability Over a One‐Year Period: A Latent State–Trait Examination
Psychophysiology · 2026-11 · 63 (11)
DOI: 10.1111/psyp.70445 ↗Abstract
ABSTRACT Vagally‐mediated heart rate variability (vmHRV) is widely proposed as a biomarker for physical and mental health, but its utility hinges on psychometric robustness, particularly temporal stability and consistency across measurement contexts. Prior reliability studies have been constrained by small samples, short retest intervals, and analytic approaches that cannot disentangle stable individual differences from situational fluctuations and measurement error. The present study examined the temporal and transsituational stability of vmHRV over a 1‐year interval in a large, population‐based sample ( N = 175) from the Dresden Burnout Study. Short‐term inter‐beat‐interval (IBI) recordings were obtained at two annual assessments under two conditions: recumbent recovery following venipuncture and seated rest. Four cardiac and HRV‐derived parameters, the established vmHRV indices root mean square of successive differences (RMSSD), percentage of successive RR intervals differing by more than 50 ms (pNN50), and high‐frequency power (HF power), complemented by mean RR interval (RR) as a general cardiac timing parameter, were analyzed using single‐trait–multistate–method‐minus‐one [STMSM(M–1)] models within the latent state–trait (LST) framework, with recovery specified as the reference condition and resting modeled as a condition‐specific method factor. Reliability ranged from 0.650 to 0.903, and trait specificity ranged from 0.375 to 0.773. RR and RMSSD showed the most consistent trait‐like profiles across occasions and conditions. pNN50 showed the highest individual trait‐specificity estimate, but also greater heterogeneity across occasions, whereas HF power showed comparatively lower trait specificity and greater occasion‐specific variance. Method specificity was small (0.034–0.087), indicating that stable condition‐specific deviations from recovery accounted for a limited proportion of variance. These findings support the interpretation of vmHRV, particularly RMSSD and pNN50, as mainly trait‐like indicators of cardiac vagal function, while also showing that single short‐term assessments contain meaningful occasion‐related variance. Standardized assessment conditions and repeated measurements remain essential for biomarker applications of vmHRV.
EUVIMED