Age Differences in the Discrimination and Level‐Specific Risk of Emergency Severity Index Triage for Critical Outcomes in the Oldest‐Old
Geriatrics & Gerontology International · 2026-11 · 26 (11)
DOI: 10.1111/ggi.70900 ↗Abstract
ABSTRACT Aim To compare Emergency Severity Index (ESI) discrimination, level‐specific risk, and under‐triage for a critical outcome between emergency department (ED) stays aged 80 years and older and 18–64 years. Methods Retrospective cohort of 418 025 ED stays of 201 214 adults with an ESI level at one US academic center, 2011–2019 (MIMIC‐IV‐ED). The critical outcome was death in the ED or hospital, or intensive care admission within 24 h. Measures were the ESI C statistic, transportability of each level's risk from 18 to 64 years, under‐triage odds (ESI 3–5 in an outcome stay), and differences after case‐mix stratification and reweighting. Results The C statistic was 0.818 at 18–64 and 0.754 at 80 and older (difference, −0.065; 95% CI, −0.072 to −0.058). The difference was −0.040 (95% CI, −0.048 to −0.033) pooled within arrival‐mode strata and −0.058 (95% CI, −0.071 to −0.046) after case‐mix reweighting. At 80 and older, observed risk was 1.96 times that carried by the same levels at 18 to 64. Specificity of ESI 1 or 2 was 48.8% versus 69.0%. Under‐triage occurred in 11.1% of outcome stays at 80 and older and 14.0% at 18–64 (adjusted odds ratio, 0.81; 95% CI, 0.73–0.90), but in 1.42 versus 0.55 per 100 stays. Conclusions At 80 years and older, ESI levels ranked critical‐outcome risk less well, a difference smaller within arrival‐mode strata, and levels 1–3 carried more risk than in younger adults. Age‐specific triage rules need prospective study.
EUVIMED