Collagen Membrane Fixation Technique Affects Its Space Maintenance Capacity After Flap Closure: An Ex Vivo Analysis
Clinical Oral Implants Research · 2026-08 · 37 (8) · 1020-1032
DOI: 10.1111/clr.70146 ↗Abstract
ABSTRACT Aims To quantify immediate graft displacement following tension‐free flap closure in non‐contained alveolar ridge defects regenerated using three membrane fixation strategies in an ex vivo human model. Methods Eighteen sites from six fresh cadaveric heads with non‐contained defects underwent horizontal guided bone regeneration using deproteinized bovine bone mineral and a collagen membrane stabilized by no fixation (NF), periosteal sutures (PS), or titanium fixation pins (FP). Techniques were applied sequentially. Cone‐beam CT scans were obtained at baseline, post‐grafting, and after passive closure. Linear ridge width was measured at 12 standardized positions, and graft volumes were segmented from STL reconstructions. Mixed‐effects multilevel linear regression assessed width changes, while Friedman and paired Wilcoxon tests evaluated volumetric outcomes, with Tukey‐adjusted contrasts for intergroup comparisons. Results Fixation pins virtually eliminated graft displacement (−6.7 ± 87 mm 3 ) and achieved the highest stability (81.2% ± 8.2%), significantly outperforming periosteal sutures (−96 ± 165 mm 3 ; 70.1% ± 4.5%) and no fixation (−247 ± 150 mm 3 ; 44.4% ± 17.9%) (loss p = 0.030; stability p = 0.002). Ridge collapse was greatest with no fixation (−1.37 ± 0.85 mm) compared with PS (−0.40 ± 0.62 mm) and FP (−0.28 ± 0.61 mm). After adjustment, PS and FP reduced collapse by 0.96 mm ( p = 0.012) and 1.11 mm ( p = 0.004), respectively. Conclusion Even after passive flap release and tension‐free closure, membrane fixation, particularly with titanium pins, provides superior resistance to graft displacement in non‐contained defects, while unfixed membranes allow substantial graft loss and are therefore not recommended in non‐contained defects.
EUVIMED