Good Science, Real Constraints: Ethics-Based Approaches to Managing Conflicting Incentives in Academic–Health System Research Partnerships
Physical Therapy · 2026-11-07
DOI: 10.1093/ptj/pzag124 ↗Abstract
Abstract Partnerships between health systems and external academic researchers are increasingly central to embedded and learning health system (LHS) research in rehabilitation. Such partnerships offer substantial promise, but they also introduce ethical and practical challenges arising from conflicting incentives related to research rigor, timelines, dissemination, financial sustainability, and academic freedom. This perspective examines these challenges through the lens of the Ethics of Research and Implementation domain of the LHS Researcher Core Competencies, grounded in the ethical principles of the physical therapy profession. Drawing on existing literature and the authors’ experience as academic–health system research partners, this perspective contrasts academic incentives (ie, grant funding, peer-reviewed publication, and generalizable knowledge) with health system incentives focused on operational efficiency, return on investment, and organizational reputation. Because health systems vary widely in their capacity to support research, this perspective presents a typology of partnership contexts and describes where ethical challenges may arise in each. This perspective then proposes ethics-based strategies for mutually beneficial research partnerships that apply across the different partnership contexts. These include transparent alignment of research goals with organizational priorities, accurate differentiation between research and quality improvement, attention to oversight particularly when a partner has less research infrastructure, pre-specification of outcomes, interim deliverables for health system stakeholders, and data use and publication agreements that protect academic freedom while allowing health system input. It illustrates these strategies with a partnership in which protected academic freedom and collaboration on dissemination allowed findings to reach national policy audiences. The Ethics of Research and Implementation competencies offer a practical framework for anticipating these conflicts and addressing them deliberately, enabling partnerships that generate rigorous knowledge while remaining useful to the health systems and patients they serve.
EUVIMED