Shifting paradigms: key tensions in putting the person’s narrative central in improving quality of care in Dutch nursing homes
The Gerontologist · 2026-11-10 · 66 (12)
DOI: 10.1093/geront/gnag236 ↗Abstract
Abstract Background and Objectives Narrative approaches to quality improvement are increasingly adopted by long-term care organizations to gain insight into quality from the perspectives of older persons. However, it remains unclear how organizations experience the organizational challenges of embedding these approaches in new quality improvement routines and policies. This study aims to investigate what tensions arise when organizing and embedding narrative approaches and how organizations respond to these tensions. Research Design and Methods An exploratory qualitative multiple-method design consisting of observations, semi-structured interviews, and document analysis was used. Data were collected in Dutch nursing homes between February 2024 and June 2025. To gain in-depth and broader insights, organizations were observed for a longer period (n = 2) and interviews were conducted with other organizations (n = 9) about organizing a narrative approach. Results Four tensions were identified: (1) steering on predetermined themes vs. emergent themes from experiences; (2) abstracting narratives into broad quality terms vs. preserving the richness of narratives; (3) organizing quality top-down and in silos vs. as a collaborative and dynamic process; and (4) accounting for compliance vs. learning for improvement. Discussion and Implications The tensions show that organizing a narrative process goes beyond organizational challenges but requires a paradigm shift in how organizations view and organize quality improvement. It requires a different way of data collection, analysis, and collaboration and emphasizes relationality and learning over individualized accounting. When organizations get stuck between two different quality paradigms, this can lead to several risks. The implications, risks, and potential of narrative approaches are discussed.
EUVIMED