Skull Base Reconstruction Following Endoscopic Endonasal Approaches: A Systematic Literature Review of Postoperative Cerebrospinal Fluid Leak Rates Across Closure Techniques
Journal of Neurological Surgery Part B: Skull Base · 2026-11-10
DOI: 10.1055/a-2994-2304 ↗Abstract
Abstract This objective of this study is to synthesize postoperative cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leak rates across all major skull base reconstruction techniques following endoscopic endonasal approaches (EEA) within a single unified framework. Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses–guided systematic review with descriptive quantitative synthesis; publication bias assessed by funnel plot with Egger's regression test. Systematic literature search of PubMed, Research Rabbit, and Google Scholar for original studies reporting postoperative CSF leak outcomes following EEA tumor resection. Eighty-nine studies published between 2004 and 2026, comprising 16,402 patients undergoing EEA for tumor resection. Pooled postoperative CSF leak rate (n/N, %) overall and stratified across seven prespecified closure categories: no closure or minimal reconstruction, fat-based closure, nasoseptal flap-based closure, free mucosal graft closure, watertight dural closure (WTDC), gasket seal and rigid buttress, and miscellaneous techniques. Overall pooled postoperative CSF leak rate was 3.11% (510/16,402). Category-level rates were no closure or minimal reconstruction 1.00% (22/2,196); fat-based closure 4.22% (123/2,916); NSF-based closure 6.29% (196/3,116); free mucosal graft 2.14% (16/748); WTDC 1.85% (24/1,295); gasket seal and rigid buttress 2.12% (104/4,898); and miscellaneous techniques 2.66% (72/2,710). Individual studies could contribute data to more than one category where applicable. No closure or minimal reconstruction and WTDC produced the lowest pooled leak rates; NSF-based closure produced the highest, reflecting preferential deployment in inherently higher-risk reconstructive scenarios rather than intrinsic inferiority. These findings provide a contemporary technique-spanning benchmark and highlight the need for prospective, intraoperative-leak-grade–stratified comparative studies to guide evidence-based closure decisions in EEA surgery.
EUVIMED