Abstract
Abstract Group therapy is rarely used in outpatient physiotherapy in Germany, although it is permitted according to the “Heilmittelrichtlinie” and would be preferable to individual therapy if equally suitable. Group therapy could help expand treatment capacities, reduce costs, and promote factors such as motivation and adherence. Whether it is similarly effective to individual therapy for diagnoses that are frequently prescribed, however, remains unclear. To provide an overview of the current evidence on group-based physiotherapy for diagnoses with high prescription rates. An overview of reviews was conducted. A systematic literature search was performed in MEDLINE, CINAHL, EBP, PEDro, OT Seeker, and Google Scholar. Systematic reviews investigating group-based physiotherapy for mobility impairments, back pain, and shoulder lesions were included. Screening and data extraction were conducted according to established standards. The methodological quality of the reviews was assessed using AMSTAR 2. The results were synthesized narratively. Fifteen systematic reviews were included, addressing back pain (n = 7) and mobility impairments (n = 8). No review on shoulder lesions was identified. Some of the reviews reported positive effects of group therapy on functional outcomes and pain compared to no treatment or usual care. Compared to individual therapy, no consistent evidence of superiority or inferiority was found. No direct negative effects of group therapy were reported. The interventions and control groups in the included reviews were mostly heterogeneous. The methodological quality of most reviews is low or critically low. Existing evidence on the effectiveness of group-based physiotherapy is limited and heterogeneous. Most included reviews are of low methodological quality; therefore, no reliable conclusions regarding the effectiveness of group therapy can be drawn. In light of current requirements of the Heilmittelrichtlinie and the high relevance for healthcare provision, there is a need for methodologically rigorous and focused systematic reviews on this topic. If these continue to reveal relevant gaps in the evidence, appropriate clinical studies should be initiated.
EUVIMED