Bladder Contractility Classification Before Bladder Outlet Surgery: Do BCI, Wmax and the Maastricht–Hannover Nomogram Agree and Does It Matter for Outcome?
Neurourology and Urodynamics · 2026-10-12
DOI: 10.1002/nau.70489 ↗Abstract
ABSTRACT Objectives The aim of this study was to assess the concordance between three classification systems (bladder contractility index, Maximum Watt's factor and Maastricht–Hannover nomogram) in allocating men to bladder contractility subgroups. Secondary aim was to explore whether preoperative contractility classification was associated with short‐term flowmetry outcomes after BOP. Materials and Methods This multicenter retrospective cohort study included men who underwent BOP (2010–2016) for lower urinary tract symptoms with available baseline urodynamic study and 6‐week postoperative flowmetry. Patients were classified according to BCI, Wmax and MH‐nomogram into very weak (BCI < 50, Wmax < 5, MH‐nomogram < 10th percentile), weak (BCI: 50–100, Wmax: 5–10, MH‐nomogram 10–25th percentile) and normal detrusor contractility (BCI > 100, Wmax > 10, MH‐nomogram > 25th percentile) subgroups. Concordance was quantified using percentage agreement and Cohen's linear weighted kappa (κ). Postoperative flowmetry outcomes were compared between subgroups within each classification and pre‐postoperative differences were determined for each subgroup. Results One hundred and thirty three patients were included (median age 69 years). Agreement was highest between BCI and Wmax (78.9%, κ = 0.61, substantial), while agreement was weak between Wmax and MH‐nomogram (48.9%, κ = 0.31) and negligible between BCI and MH‐nomogram (37.6%, κ = 0.05). All subgroups showed improvement Qmax and PVR parameters after BOP, with no significant association found between preoperative contractility grade and postoperative outcomes. Conclusions BCI, Wmax and the MH‐nomogram show only limited concordance, particularly involving the MH‐nomogram, and cannot be regarded as interchangeable. Contractility classification was not associated with postoperative outcomes, and all subgroups improved after BOP. These findings underscore the need for a clinically relevant urodynamic consensus definition of DU and support shared decision‐making over classification‐based patient selection alone.
EUVIMED