Semi‐Quantitative Detection of Respiratory Pathogens: A Systematic Review and Meta‐Analysis of Results From the BIOFIRE FILMARRAY Pneumonia Panel and Culture
MicrobiologyOpen · 2026-02 · 15 (1)
DOI: 10.1002/mbo3.70086 ↗Abstract
ABSTRACT This systematic review and meta‐analysis compared bacterial semi‐quantification of respiratory samples from the BIOFIRE FILMARRAY Pneumonia (PN) Panels with quantitative and semi‐quantitative culture methods (qCMs). Fourteen studies comprising 1,654 samples were included. Across both bronchoalveolar lavage‐like and endotracheal aspirate‐like specimens, the BIOFIRE PN Panel reported consistently higher bacterial loads than qCMs, with pooled mean differences of 1.17 and 0.95 log, respectively. Discrepancies decreased as culture‐reported bacterial burden increased. The concordance rate in identifying the predominant pathogen was 94%, supporting the panel's clinical relevance. However, differential reporting at lower bacterial loads suggests that existing culture‐based thresholds may not translate directly to molecular diagnostics. These findings highlight the need for pathogen‐ and method‐specific interpretive thresholds to optimize the diagnostic utility of semi‐quantitative molecular results and inform antimicrobial stewardship decisions.
EUVIMED