Diagnostic accuracy of transmucosal probe visualization for peri‐implant mucosal phenotype assessment: A cross‐sectional study
Journal of Periodontology · 2026-07 · 97 (7) · 1407-1417
DOI: 10.1002/jper.70062 ↗Abstract
Abstract Background This study evaluated the diagnostic accuracy of visual assessment of mucosal transparency using a standard periodontal probe (VAT) to differentiate between thin and thick peri‐implant mucosal phenotypes, compared to horizontal transmucosal probing (HTP). A secondary objective was to assess facial mucosal thickness (FMT) threshold values for peri‐implant mucosa phenotype classification. Methods Adult subjects with at least one non‐molar single implant‐supported prosthesis (ISP) were screened. To evaluate VAT, a standard periodontal probe was inserted through the peri‐implant sulcus on the midfacial aspect. FMT was measured via HTP using an endodontic spreader. Results A total of 247 subjects and 281 ISPs constituted the study population. Setting a 2 mm threshold, 66.2% of sites were classified as thick and 33.8% as thin. Compared to HTP, VAT demonstrated a sensitivity (SE) of 12.6%, a specificity (SP) of 96.2%, a positive predictive value (PPV) of 63%, and a negative predictive value (NPV) of 66%. At the 1.5 mm threshold, 86.1% of sites were thick and 13.9% thin, with 25.6% SE, 96.3% SP, 53% PPV, and 89% NPV. At the 1 mm threshold, 92.2% of sites were thick and 7.8% thin, with 41% SE, 96% SP, 47% PPV, and 95% NPV. Receiver operating characteristic analysis revealed the best‐fitting balance for PPV (58%) and NPV (91%) at an FMT of 1.25 mm. Conclusions Regardless of the FMT threshold applied, VAT demonstrated limited diagnostic accuracy, in particular for thin phenotypes, proving unreliable for the dichotomic characterization of thin and thick peri‐implant mucosal phenotypes. This study was approved by the ethical committee for clinical studies in the canton of Bern, Switzerland (KEK‐BE‐No. 2023‐01962).
EUVIMED