EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
CrossrefInfokarte

Trustworthiness assessment as an inclusion criterion for systematic reviews—What is the impact on results?

Jo Weeks, Anna Cuthbert, Zarko Alfirevic

Cochrane Evidence Synthesis and Methods · 2023-12 · 1 (10)

DOI: 10.1002/cesm.12037 ↗
AbstractBibliografische Angaben

Abstract

Abstract Background There is increasing concern that a significant proportion of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) included in Cochrane reviews may not be trustworthy. Applying the Cochrane Pregnancy and Childbirth Trustworthiness Screening Tool (CPC‐TST) has already had a clinically important effect on several reviews published by the Cochrane Pregnancy and Childbirth Group. Objectives We wanted to assess the impact of removing untrustworthy RCTs from already‐published Cochrane reviews on a defined clinical area (antenatal and postnatal nutritional interventions). Methods We applied the tool to 18 Cochrane reviews (374 RCTs). The tool had four domains: (i) is the research governance trustworthy; (ii) are the baseline characteristics trustworthy; (iii) is the study feasible; (iv) are the results plausible? When additional information was needed, authors were contacted using a standard template. At least two attempts were made to contact the authors. At the end of the evaluation process each study was classified as: (i) included (YES to all questions); (ii) excluded (retracted study); or (iii) awaiting classification (any NO to the questions). Results Ninety‐three out of 374 included studies (25%) were reclassified as “excluded” or “awaiting classification.” The number of included RCTs was reduced in 14 out of 18 reviews. Six reviews (33%) were judged to require updating because of important differences in the Summary of Findings tables (direction and size of effects and/or GRADE ratings), conclusions, implication for practice, and/or implication for research. Conclusions Formal assessment of trustworthiness, and inclusion only of studies that satisfy prespecified criteria for trustworthiness, affect conclusions in a relatively large number of Cochrane reviews, with potentially important clinical implications for practice and research.

Wissen, das zu Ihrer Arbeit passt.

Vom kostenlosen Einstieg über die persönliche Recherche bis zur vollständigen Research Suite.

Tarife ansehen →

Sind alle Verlagsvolltexte enthalten?

Nein. Bibliografische Nachweise, Abstracts und Volltexte sind unterschiedliche Inhalte. Ob ein Volltext verfügbar ist, hängt von der Quelle, Open Access und Ihren vorhandenen Lizenzen ab. Ein EUVIMED-Tarif ersetzt keine zusätzlichen Verlagsrechte.

Tarife ansehen →