Treatment plan quality comparison between ZAP‐Axon ® Krylov optimizer and Leksell Gamma Knife ® Lightning optimizer for brain metastasis
Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics · 2026-11 · 27 (11)
DOI: 10.1002/acm2.70851 ↗Abstract
Abstract Purpose This study compares stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) treatment plan quality between the recently launched ZAP‐Axon ® Krylov optimizer and the Leksell Gamma Knife ® (LGK) Lightning optimizer for brain metastasis (BM). Methods Thirty ( n = 30) patients who were previously treated with LGK SRS or fractionated SRS were selected and divided into three groups: large post‐operative resection cavities of BM (BM lg, postop ), large intact BM (BM lg, intact ) and small intact BM (BM sm, intact ). Based on our institutional planning guidelines, the 30 clinical cases were replanned using ZAP‐Axon Krylov and LGK Lightning optimizers without manual adjustments. Statistical analysis was performed to compare plan quality metrics (Paddick conformity index [PCI], gradient index [GI], target coverage [TC], prescribed isodose line [Rx IDL], and treatment time/scaled beam‐on‐time [sBOT] [min]) between the two optimizers. Results For the BM lg, postop group, mean values of PCI, GI, TC, Rx IDL, and treatment time/sBOT (min) for Krylov versus Lightning plans were 0.91 versus 0.91, 2.48 versus 2.56, 99.5% versus 99.7%, 51.1% versus 53.7% and 37.4 min versus 36.5 min, respectively. All metrics except for the Rx IDL (%) were not statistically significantly different. For the BM lg, intact group, corresponding values were 0.93 versus 0.93, 2.42 versus 2.57, 99.5% versus 99.7%. 51.5% versus 53.0% and 35.9 min versus 36.3 min. While GI was statistically significantly different ( p
EUVIMED